The ULTIMATE LIST of HUNDREDS of cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save items: Filler items to help you get up to five, and save more on your higher cost subscriptions!
Last updated 5/19/22
- As of the time & date of this post: Each Subscribe & Save filler item here is under $2.00 shipped on the five+ items tier.
- Add in one or two of these low cost fillers, & you’ll save more on your higher priced Subscribe & Save items.
- Browse all Amazon Subscribe & Save items here.
As always, prices on Amazon can change at any time. Always check the current price before subscribing. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Hundreds of cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save items: Under $2.00 each as of May 19, 2022
These Subscribe & Save filler items are under $2.00 each on the five items tier at the time of this post (since this is our goal!). Post is updated every Thursday.
*** Items marked New! are new to (or making a reappearance on) the list since last week.
Food & drink filler items
- New! Abuelita Mexican style instant hot chocolate mix
- New! Excelsior water crackers
- New! San Marcos whole jalapeño peppers 26 oz
- New! Jumex peach nectar 33.8 oz
- New! Campbell’s condensed cheddar cheese soup
- Twin pack beef pasta Hamburger Helper
- Jack Link’s beef sticks, one teriyaki meat stick
- San Marcos chipotles in adobo 7.5 oz
- 12 oz Contadina roma tomato paste
- Campbell’s condensed cream of chicken soup can
- Swiss Miss salted caramel cocoa mix 8 pack
- Diamond chopped walnuts 2.25 oz
- Six pack Sun-Maid raisins snack packs
- Green Giant:
- Del Monte:
- Chef Boyardee mac & cheese can
- Snack Pack:
- Can of Ro-Tel
- Zatarain’s rice:
- Happy Belly 32 oz chicken stock
- True Lemon Kids fruit punch drink mix 10 ct
Condiment, baking, & seasoning filler items
- New! Heinz Kansas City sweet & smoky BBQ sauce
- Thai Kitchen gluten free green curry paste
- Log Cabin all natural pancake mix 28 oz
- The Spice Hunter mint leaves .36 oz jar
- 10 oz Heinz dill relish
- 8 oz Bar Harbor clam juice
- Watkins organic seasoning:
- Watkins organic gourmet meatloaf seasoning mix
- Watkins organic gourmet beef stew seasoning mix
- Watkins organic gourmet au jus gravy seasoning mix
- Watkins organic mild chili seasoning mix
- Watkins organic pot roast seasoning mix
- Watkins organic garlic & herb marinade
- Watkins organic gourmet turkey gravy seasoning mix
- Zatarain’s:
- Clabber Girl:
- Happy Belly extracts & food colorings:
- 6 oz Jell-O berry blue gelatin mix
- Simply Organic southwest taco seasoning mix
- Kitchen Accomplice:
McCormick seasonings, extracts, salad toppings, & mixes filler items
- New! McCormick imitation bac’n pieces
- McCormick sea salt grinder
- McCormick pure pumpkin pie spice blend extract 1 oz
- McCormick Grill Mates seasonings & mixes:
- McCormick Grill Mates chipotle pepper marinade mix
- McCormick Grill Mates Baja citrus marinade mix
- McCormick Grill Mates garlic, herb, & wine marinade mix
- McCormick Grill Mates smokehouse maple seasoning
- McCormick Grill Mates tomato, garlic, & basil marinade mix
- McCormick Grill Mates Brazilian steakhouse marinade mix
- McCormick Grill Mates Montreal steak marinade mix
- McCormick mixes:
- McCormick less sodium chili seasoning mix
- McCormick onion gravy mix
- McCormick turkey gravy mix
- McCormick mushroom gravy mix
- McCormick 30% less sodium brown gravy mix
- McCormick original chili seasoning mix
- McCormick gluten free chili seasoning mix
- McCormick beef stew seasoning mix
- McCormick 30% less sodium mild chili seasoning mix
- McCormick guacamole seasoning mix
- McCormick fajita seasoning mix
- McCormick slow cooker BBQ pulled pork seasoning mix
Salad dressing filler items
- Wish-Bone dressing:
- Wish-Bone sweet & spicy honey mustard dressing
- Wish-Bone chipotle ranch dressing
- Wish-Bone creamy French dressing
- Wish-Bone light sweet & spicy French dressing
- Wish-Bone fat free chunky blue cheese dressing
- Wish-Bone zesty robusto Italian dressing 15 oz
- Wish-Bone light ranch dressing
- Wish-Bone light raspberry walnut vinaigrette
- Wish-Bone Russian salad dressing
- Western French fat free salad dressing
- Happy Belly dressing:
- Kraft salad dressing:
Personal care filler items
- New! Blistex medicated lip ointment
- New! Lever 2000 bar soap, original 2 bars
- Kleenex cooling lotion facial tissues 45 ct
- Listerine:
- SoftSheen-Carson magic shave powder for men
- GUM stimulator refills 3 ct
- Aquafresh:
- Colgate Kids cavity protection paste in bubble fruit
- Summer’s Eve fragrance free 16 ct cleansing wipes
- Vagisil scentsitive scents on-the-go feminine cleansing mini wipes, peach blossom 16 ct
- Softsoap liquid hand soap, aloe
- Lip Smackers unicorn hand sanitizer
- 20 ct Carefree regular liners
- Reach mint waxed dental floss
- 12 ct Plackers micro mint dental floss picks with travel case
- 5 ct double edge safety razor blades by Kai
- Himalaya purifying neem & turmeric cleansing bar
Cosmetics filler items
- New! Rimmel Provocalips lip stain, just teasing
- New! Sally Hansen hard as nails color, limestone
- New! wet ‘n wild color icon matte eye shadow, brulee
- New! Revlon:
- Lip Smacker cotton candy lip gloss
- Black Radiance:
- NYX:
- Revlon:
- e.l.f.:
- Sally Hansen nail:
- L.A. Colors high shine shea butter lip gloss, sensual
- L.A. Colors eye:
- L.A. Colors nail:
- wet ‘n wild nail:
- wet ‘n wild eye:
- wet ‘n wild brow-sessive brow pencil in light brown/taupe
- wet ‘n wild mega last breakup-proof retractable eyeliner, black
- wet ‘n wild mega clear brow & lash mascara
- wet ‘n wild color icon kohl liner pencil, pretty in mink
- wet ‘n wild color icon glitter eyeshadow, shimmer bleached
- wet ‘n wild color icon kohl eyeliner pencil, baby’s got black
- wet ‘n wild enhance & define megawear mascara, black
- wet ‘n wild lip:
- wet ‘n wild mega last high shine lip color, fire-fighting
- wet ‘n wild mega last high shine lip color in pinky ring
- wet ‘n wild silk finish lipstick in black orchid
- wet ‘n wild silk finish lip stick in Just Garnet
- wet ‘n wild megaslicks lip gloss in rose gold
- wet ‘n wild megaslicks lip gloss in sinless
- wet ‘n wild mega slicks lip gloss, call me boss
- wet ‘n wild mega slicks lip gloss in love language
- wet ‘n wild silk finish lipstick, breeze nude
- wet ‘n wild mega slicks lip gloss, crushed grapes
- wet ‘n wild mega slicks lip gloss in champagne please
- wet ‘n wild silk finish lipstick, in the near fuschia
- wet ‘n wild color icon lip liner, plumberry
Other Beauty filler items
- New! TRIM 2 ct salon boards
- Dynex body wash and conditioner 8 oz
- Yardley:
- Aussie 3 minute miracle moist deep conditioning treatment
- KISS powerflex nail glue
- L.A. Colors drip proof nail glue
- OKAY black Jamaican castor oil leave-in conditioner
- butter LONDON banana nail file
- Wella color charm painting bayalage hair developer 2 oz
- Clairol true color cream developer
- Palmer’s cocoa butter & biotin length retention biotin packet
- Pantene Pro-V intense rescue shots hair ampoule
- Cutex Strength Shield nail polish remover
- FILA fragrance:
- JOICO:
- Neutrogena:
- Diane:
- e.l.f.:
- wet ‘n wild brushes and tools:
- HELI’s Gold voluminize shampoo
- Malibu C un-do-goo > pH 9 shampoo packet
- L’ANZA .25 oz color care trauma treatment shampoo
Health filler items
- New! Ricola cherry honey throat drops 24 ct
- New! 100 ct BD alcohol swabs
- Tylenol extra strength caplets 10 ct travel pack
- First Aid Only SmartCompliance refill 5×9 trauma pad 2 ct
- Pure L-Tyrosine 8 oz powder
- 30 ct Luden’s wild cherry throat drops
- Ricola 24 ct lemonmint herb throat drops
- Radians 6 pack foam earplugs
- Fleet laxative saline enema
- Apex dayplanner
- Band-Aid:
- GoodSense saline nasal spray
- Solimo isopropyl alcohol:
Household filler items
- New! Sprayway 20 ct glass cleaner wipes
- New! Energizer 2016 3V lithium coin battery
- New! Wrights bias tape:
- New! HeatnBond hem iron-on adhesive, regular weight, white
- Wrights bias tape:
- HeatnBond iron-on hem adhesive, super weight, white
- Carlisle alibi heavy weight plastic shooter glass
- Miracle-Gro pour & feed singles plant food
- Victor 4 pack snap mouse traps
- Air Wick:
- Scrubbing Bubbles toilet bowl cleaner
- Arm & Hammer:
- Light bulbs:
- Sylvania LED bulb, 75W equivalent A19 bright white
- Sylvania LED bulb, 75W equivalent A19 frosted finish
- Sylvania LED bulb, 60W equivalent A19 frosted finish
- Satco S3364 120V medium base F15 bulb
- Bulbrite KR15CFC/25 15W Krystal Touch flame tip chandelier bulb, candelabra base
- Bulbrite KR10CFC/25 10W flame tip chandelier bulb
- Bulbrite 10W Krystal Touch CA8 chandelier bulb
- Satco S3171 10 watt 120 lumens T3 halogen G4 base 12 volt clear dimmable bulb
- Glade air:
Tools & automotive filler items
- Cooling bandana, stars & stripes
- IRWIN tools strait-line lumber crayon, black
- Danco perfect match 24184 stem repair kit for sterling
- Dynamic clear rolled drop cloth
- FoamPRO 103 foam paint roller
- Mahle B45693 engine oil pump pickup tube o-ring
- Safety/work gloves:
- Refresh Your Car vent sticks 4 pack, rejuvenating ocean breeze
- Fel-Pro:
- HEET gas line antifreeze 12 oz
- Vibra-TITE threadlockers:
- Camco 41515 rhino tank treatment 4 oz
- Kohler 74903 replacement washer
- Omix-Ada 19105.08 wiper rod clip
- NOCO NCP2 MC303 battery terminal protectors 2 pack
- Frost King vinyl foam weatherseal tape
- Electrical tape:
- Plymouth Revere general purpose electrical tape, yellow
- Plymouth Revere general purpose electrical tape, gray
- NSi WarriorWrap Select vinyl electrical tape, yellow
- NSi WarriorWrap Select vinyl electrical tape, green
- NSi WarriorWrap Select vinyl electrical tape, gray
- NSi WarriorWrap Select vinyl electrical tape, brown
- Trimaco SuperTuff cone strainer medium mesh 4 pack
- Linzer 8500 0100 paint brush 1″
- GAM wall scraper
- TapeCase white bag sealing tape roll
Pet filler items
Dogs & cats
- Van Ness pureness F6 zeolite air filter
- Pioneer Pet balls for cats
- Hartz just for cats bizzy balls
- Petmate zeolite charcoal filter
- Arm & Hammer cat litter deodorizer
- Pro Pac:
- Pioneer pet toy balls for cats 3 ct
- Nylabone Extreme Chew chicken flavored toy bone for petite X-small dogs
- Plato Thinkers treats:
Other household pets
- New! Vitakraft Crunch sticks parakeet treat
- New! Penn-Plax cuttlebone with holder, medium
- Python:
- Peter’s Nature Treats for small animals, apple slices
- MarineLand:
- Zoo Med hermit crab mineral blocks
- Tetra:
- Fluval edge foam & biomax filter media renewal kit
- Marina intake strainer sponge slim power filter
- Exo Terra adult aquatic turtle food
- Kaytee food from the wild:
Office, school, arts, & crafts filler items
Office & school supplies
- New! Pentel twist-erase click mechanical pencil, .7 mm black barrel
- C-LINE CD/document ring binder pages 10 pack
- ACCO 1.5″ square magnetic clip, silver
- Brady 97200 Bradyfoam white mounting tape card mounted
- National Kolor Kraft college ruled blue notebook
- General Pencil tri-tip eraser
- Pilot:
- Prang chalk:
- Business Source:
- Office Essentials plastic insertable dividers, 8-tab letter
- Officemate pencil style moistener with wedge sponge
- Pentel:
- Pentel hi-polymer lead .7 mm HB, tube of 30
- Pentel hi-polymer lead .7mm medium 2H 12 pack, black
- Pentel refill ink for EnerGel liquid gel pen, needle tip, black ink
- Pentel Arts hi-polymer white cap erasers 10 ct
- Pentel twist-erase click mechanical pencil .7 mm black barrel
- Pentel hi-polymer lead refills, .5mm HB 30 ct
- Pentel refill ink for EnerGel liquid gel pen, .7mm red
- Pentel super hi-polymer lead refills, .7mm HB tube of 30
- BIC:
- BIC pencil lead refills, medium point .7mm 30 ct black
- BIC Brite Liner highlighter chisel tip 5 ct
- BIC Atlantis original retractable ball pen, medium point blue 2 ct
- BIC pencil lead refills fine point .5 mm 30 ct
- BIC round stic Xtra Life ballpoint pens, blue 10 ct
- BIC round stic Xtra life ballpoint pens, red 10 ct
- Avery office supplies:
- Avery labels:
- Avery fashion reinforcement labels 280 ct assorted metallic colors
- Avery round color coding labels 315 pack
- Avery 1×3 rectangular color coding labels 72 pack
- Avery removable labels, rectangular, white, 525 ct
- Avery removable multi-use labels, blue border, 10 pack
- Avery removable multi-use labels, blue border 15 pack
- Avery 315 ct multi-use round removable labels
- Avery all-purpose labels 1.5×2.75″ white pack of 76
- Avery permanent file folder labels 156 ct
- Avery removable color-coding labels, neon 180 ct
- Avery Hello My Name Is name tags, 25 ct
- Avery all purpose labels 1×2.75″, white, pack of 128
- Avery dividers:
- Lion Design poly yellow envelope
Arts & crafts
- New! UCHIDA Le Neon pen, blue
- New! FolkArt paint:
- New! DecoArt paint:
- New! Edding 1225 calligraphy pen, bottlegreen
- New! Bernat Handicrafter cotton yarn ombres, fruit punch ombre
- New! Prismacolor:
- Apple Barrel paint:
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint, orange cream
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint, green turquoise
- Apple Barrel glow-in-the-dark acrylic paint, yellow
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint, dark blue gray
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint, orange sherbert
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint, light lavender
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint, bright yellow
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint, pink parfait
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint, pink polish
- Apple Barrel satin acrylic paint, black
- Apple Barrel gloss acrylic paint, hot rod red
- Apple Barrel gloss acrylic paint, golden yellow
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint, barn red
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint, kelly green
- Best Creation washi tape:
- DecoArt paint:
- DecoArt Americana acrylic paint, royal fuchsia
- DecoArt Americana multi-surface satin acrylics paint, coffee bean
- DecoArt Americana acrylic paint, true blue
- DecoArt Americana acrylic paint, Indian turquoise
- DecoArt dazzling metallics 2 oz white pearl acrylic paint
- DecoArt Americana acrylic paint, lamp black
- FolkArt paint:
- 12 red Crayola crayons
- S&S Worldwide:
- Delta Creative paint:
- Apple Barrel acrylic paint 2 oz, key west
- Scotch glue stick
- Cra-Z Art:
- Prismacolor:
- PILOT parallel mixable color ink refills for calligraphy pens, turquoise 6 pack
- STABILO:
- Sharpie:
*** This list is updated each Thursday.
New to Amazon Subscribe & Save?
I’ve got your back! Here’s your step-by-step guide showing how to maximize your savings with Amazon Subscribe & Save.
And, if you’re wondering how to cancel these subscriptions when they’re no longer needed: Here’s your step-to-step guide showing how to cancel Amazon Subscribe & Save.
Prices on Amazon often change quickly; price(s) current as of the time and date of this post. You can cancel subscribe & save or skip a shipment at any time. On many items, you get 5% off and free shipping with Subscribe & Save, or 15% off if you have five subscriptions arriving at the same time.