Last updated 1/21/21
Here are 100+ cheap Amazon subscribe & save items to help you get up to five subscriptions, for that magical 15% off most things in your subscribe & save order!
- At the time & date of this post: Each subscribe & save filler item here is under $2.00 shipped on the 15% off (or five items) tier.
- Add in one or two of these low cost fillers, & you’ll save more on your higher priced subscribe & save items.
As always, prices on Amazon can change at any time. Always check the current price before subscribing. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
100+ Cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save items under $2.00 each as of January 21, 2021
Subscribe & save filler items under $2.00 each on the five items tier at the time of this post (since this is our goal!). Post is updated every Thursday.
Items marked New! are new to (or making a reappearance on) the list since last week.
Food & drink filler items
- New! Jell-O lime gelatin mix 6 oz
- New! 4 pack apple cinnamon GoGo squeeZ
- New! 11 oz Mother’s Circus animal cookies
- New! Thai Kitchen unsweetened coconut milk
- New! Dole fruit bowls, mixed fruit in sugar free cherry flavored gel
- New! 16 oz Happy Belly creamy peanut butter
- Duncan Hines mug cakes caramel flavored brownie mix 4 pack
- Ro-Tel 10 oz diced tomatoes & green chilies
- Jell-O banana cream instant pudding mix
- 4 ct Snack Pack vanilla pudding cups
- So Delicious 1 quart organic vanilla coconutmilk
- Bumble Bee Snow’s minced clams
- Wyler’s Mrs. Grass extra noodles soup mix
- Zatarain’s Spanish rice or Zatarain’s red beans & rice
- Twin pack Hamburger Helper stroganoff
- Wasa 7 grain crispbread
- Swanson vegetable broth can
- Annie’s peace pasta & Parmesan
- Capri Sun Pacific Cooler 10 pack
- True Lime limeade black cherry 10 ct
- Excelsior cinnamon water crackers 11.85 oz
- YumEarth gummy bears 2.5 oz bag
Condiments, baking items, & seasonings filler items
- New! Happy Belly chili powder 2.75 oz
- New! 8 oz Lawry’s seasoned salt
- New! McCormick mushroom gravy mix
- New! Lawry’s lemon pepper marinade
- New! Kitchen Accomplice wicked tasty taco simmer sauce
- New! Kraft classic Catalina salad dressing
- Lawry’s steakhouse marinade 12 oz or Lawry’s Caribbean jerk marinade 12 oz
- 20 oz Heinz tomato ketchup
- McCormick buffalo wings seasoning mix
- Classico traditional pizza sauce
- Zatarain’s crawfish, shrimp, & crab boil
- Heinz 10 oz sweet relish
- McCormick cocktail sauce for seafood
- Happy Belly balsamic vinaigrette or Happy Belly buttermilk ranch dressing or Happy Belly blue cheese dressing or Happy Belly creamy Caesar or Happy Belly California French style dressing
- McCormick mushroom gravy mix
- Kraft olive oil Caesar dressing or Kraft Tuscan House Italian dressing or Kraft chunky blue cheese dressing
- Wish-Bone ranch dressing or Wish-Bone chunky blue cheese dressing or Wish-Bone fat free chunky blue cheese dressing or red wine vinaigrette or light ranch dressing or Wish-Bone Russian dressing or zesty Robusto Italian dressing or Wish-Bone light sweet & spicy French dressing or Wish-Bone sweet & spicy honey mustard dressing
- Equal zero calorie 100 ct sweetener tablets
Personal care filler items
- New! Reach waxed mint dental floss 55 yards
- New! Softsheen-Carson magic shaving powder for men
- Suave fresh deodorant for women
- 3 pack Irish Spring deodorant bar soap
- ChapStick 100% natural lip butter in green tea mint
- Speed Stick deodorant in musk
- Dial liquid hand soap in cherry blossom & almond
- 3.2 oz Listerine ultraclean
- Colgate baking soda & peroxide toothpaste
- Coppertone Sport sunscreen lip balm
- 75 ct Plackers back teeth micro mint dental floss picks or 12 ct Plackers micro mint dental floss picks with travel case
- Softsoap liquid hand soap in pomegranate mango
- 1 oz Gold Bond body powder
- Himalayan purifying neem & turmeric cleansing bar
- ACE all purpose 7″ hair comb
- Translucent toothbrush holder
- Aquafresh cavity protection paste
- Blistex Five Star lip protection
- .9 fl oz OPI Swiss Blue liquid hand soap
- Summer’s Eve 16 ct sunset oasis cleansing cloth
- Almay clear gel sensitive skin deodorant
- Brush Buddies denture brush
Cosmetics filler items
- New! Revlon nail enamel in totally toffee
- New! e.l.f. satin eyeliner pencil with built-in sharpener or e.l.f. instant lift brow pencil
- New! wet ‘n wild megalast lip color in don’t blink pink
- New! L.A. Colors Color Craze nail polish in treasure island
- New! L.A. Girl eyeliner pencil
- L.A. Colors chunky lip pencil in lilac or L.A. Colors chunky lip pencil in coral or L.A. Colors chunky lip pencil in warm caramel or L.A. Colors chunky lip pencil in tierra cotta
- Sally Hansen hard as nails color, heart of stone or Sally Hansen hard as nails color, cold as ice
- wet ‘n wild megalast nail color, haze of love
- wet ‘n wild mega last high shine lip color in rose and slay
- L.A. Colors brow pencil with spool or L.A. Colors 2-piece eyeliner/brow pencil with sharpener
- wet ‘n wild megaslicks lip gloss in rose gold or wet ‘n wild megaslicks lip gloss in red sensation or wet ‘n wild megaslicks lip gloss in cotton candy
- wet ‘n wild megalast lip color in cherry bomb or in fire-fighting or wet ‘n wild megalast lip color in cinnamon spice
- silk finish lip stick in Just Garnet or wet n wild silk finish lip stick in blind date
Other Beauty filler items
- New! One Direction Our Moment for women with eau de parfum spray vial
- New! Yes to Cucumbers paper mask
- New! Queen Helene cocoa butter face & body creme
- e.l.f. eyeshadow brush for precision application or e.l.f. dual-pencil sharpener
- wet n wild small concealer brush or wet n wild crease brush or wet ‘n wild large eyeshadow brush or small eyeshadow brush or wet ‘n wild angled liner brush
- Aussie 3 minute miracle moist deep conditioning treatment
- Diane slant tip tweezer
- The Face Shop real nature mask sheet in olive
- Palmer’s coconut oil protein pack
- Yardley cocoa butter & vitamin E bar soap
- Cutex strength shield nail polish remover
- Niuta colossal foot rasp
- Clairol professional pure white hair developers for lightening or professional developers for lightening
- Revlon compact mini nail clipper
- Diane wood applicator sticks
- 7 ct Neutrogena makeup remover towelettes
- HELI’s GOLD restructure masque or HELI’s GOLD crystal cream serum or HELI’s Gold weightless conditioner or HELI’s Gold voluminize shampoo or Heli’s Gold revitalize shampoo
- .25 oz L’ANZA healing colorcare clarifying shampoo
Health filler items
- 10 ct morning pep prenatal vitamin tablets
- Band-Aid 50 ct tru-stay clear spots bandages
- First Aid Only hydrocortisone anti-itch cream 12 ct packets
- Ricola 24 ct honey-herb cough drops
- Pac-Kit by First Aid Only 3″ gauze roll bandage
- Luden’s 30 ct honey licorice cough drops or 25 ct Luden’s sugar free wild cherry cough drops
- First Aid Only scissors & tweezers pack
- Good Sense saline nasal spray
- First Aid Only gauze compress
- Fleet laxative saline enema 2 ct
Household filler items
- New! Duracell 2032 3V lithium coin battery
- New! Decorative nails in antique brass, 24 piece
- Scotch-Brite 3 pack plastic scrubbing pads
- Glade solid air freshener in lavender & peach blossom
- 20 ct Sprayaway glass cleaner wipes
- Wire nails 2 oz pack or panel nails or linoleum nails
- Duracell 2016 3V lithium coin battery
- GE Lighting 2 pack C7 blue light bulbs
- Air Wick stick ups car air freshener in crisp breeze
- Danco perfect match 24184 stem repair kit for sterling
- Magid gemstone diamond protective visitor glasses
- Kohler 1060514 handle insert
- 40 ct Purex dryer sheets in mountain breeze
- Fels Naptha laundry bar & stain remover
Pet filler items
Dogs & cats
- New! SmartyKat catnip cat toys or SmartyKat cat toys with feathers
- New! Hartz Cattraction silver vine & catnip cat toys
- New! Mega Bones mega p’nut butter junior bone or Mega Bones mega cheez junior bone
- Bonies natural dental bones small singles
- Basic litter pan Zeolite filter
- SmartyKat bouncy mouse
- Pro Pac Chick’n’meal sticks treats or Pro Pac smoky sausage bites dog treats or Pro Pac beef flavored woof ’em down sticks dog treats or Pro Pac bacon flavored jerky strips dog treats
- Arm & Hammer cat litter deodorizer
- JW Playplace butterfly teether or JW Pet Company iSqueak ball rubber dog toy
- Mammoth flossy chews rope tug toy for dogs
- Vet Worthy adhering wrap for dogs or Vet Worthy pet pill gun for dogs
- Plato Thinkers real meat sticks dog treats
- Whisker Lickin’s tuna cat treats
- Purebites Mixers pure wild tuna in water for cats
Fish, amphibians, & reptiles
- New! API tropical pellets fish food
- Fluval underwater filter in poly/carbon
- Wardley goldfish pellet food
- MarineLand penguin power filter cartridge
- API aquarium test strips
- Tetra Whisper whisper filter cartridges for aquariums
- Fluker’s gourmet style river shrimp
- Aqueon marine flakes
- Wardley weekend feeder
- Marina 2″ black coarse nylon net or Marina Blue fine nylon net with handle or Marina floating thermometer with suction cup
- 6 pack Zilla reptile food cricket water pillows
- Fluval Edge digital aquarium thermometer or Fluval A1175 air plastic control valve
- Tetra Correct pH tablets 8 ct
- TetraMin tropical tablets for bottom feeders
- TetraCichlid floating pellets
- ExoTerra adult aquatic turtle food
- Penn Plax airline tubing for aquariums or Penn Plax quick net for fish
- Fluker’s repta calcium
- Tetra weekend tropical slow release feeder
- ExoTerra dual carbon pads
- Van Ness F6 Zeolite air filter
- Tetra BettaMin floating mini pellets for bettas
Birds
Other small animals
- New! Wild Harvest yogies for guinea pigs and adult rabbits
- Kaytee small animal potty training litter
- Living World small animals minerals stone, carrot
- Vitakraft rabbit slims with carrot
- Vitakraft Nibble Rings small animal treat
- Kaytee food from the wild natural snack
- nBone ferret chews in bacon flavor or nBone ferret chews in salmon flavor
- Vitakraft Slims with alfalfa
- Ware large rice pops small animal treats
Office and Art Supplies filler items
- Avantus self adhesive mailing labels
- 5 ct Bic Brite Liner highlighters
- Avery GlueStic for envelopes
- Avery durable labels for kids gear
- Avery triangle shaped sheet lifter for 3 ring binder
- Single subject wire bound notebook
- Universal lightweight hand letter opener
- Avery big tab dividers for 2 prong classification folders, set of 5 or Avery Worksaver extra-wide insertable tab recycled dividers or Avery write-on dividers for two-prong classification folders or Avery WorkSaver tab inserts 3.5 inches 100 ct or Avery WorkSaver tab inserts 2 inches 100 ct
*** This list is updated each Thursday.
More Amazon deals?
If you just can’t get enough of that Amazon subscribe & save and other deals:
- Browse all Amazon subscribe & save items (and see current subscribe & save coupons!) here.
- Come join us in the Hot Deals Facebook group.
New to Amazon subscribe & save?
I’ve got your back! Here’s your step-by-step guide showing how to maximize your savings with Amazon subscribe & save.
Prices on Amazon often change quickly; price(s) current as of the time and date of this post. You can cancel subscribe & save or skip a shipment at any time. On MOST items, you get 5% off and free shipping with subscribe & save, or 15% off if you have five subscriptions on the same day/month. For more about coupons & subscribe & save, see the guide here.