100+ cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save Items — Updated 9/24/20

Last updated 9/24/20

Here are 100+ cheap Amazon subscribe & save items to help you get up to five subscriptions, for that magical 15% off most things in your subscribe & save order!

• At the time & date of this post: Each subscribe & save filler item here is under $2.00 shipped on the 15% off (or five items) tier.
• Add in one or two of these low cost fillers, & you’ll save more on your higher priced subscribe & save items.

As always, prices on Amazon can change at any time. Always check the current price before subscribing. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

100+ Cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save items under $2.00 each as of September 24, 2020

Subscribe & save filler items under $2.00 each on the five items tier at the time of this post (since this is our goal!). Post is updated every Thursday. Items marked New! are new to (or making a reappearance on) the list since last week.

Food filler items

1. New! 16 oz Happy Belly creamy peanut butter
2. New! Zatarain’s Spanish rice
3. New! Jell-O sugar free instant cheesecake pudding
4. Musco Family early California medium pitted olives
5. Twin pack stroganoff Hamburger Helper
6. Zatarains red beans & rice
7. Quaker big chewy chocolate chip granola bars
8. Bumble Bee Snow’s minced clams in clam juice
9. Can of Swanson vegetable broth
10. True Lime limeade black cherry 10 ct
11. 9 oz bag of Skittles
12. Excelsior cinnamon water crackers 11.85 oz
13. Annie’s mac & cheese peace pasta & Parmesan
14. YumEarth gummy bears 2.5 oz bag

Condiments, baking items, & seasonings filler items

1. New! 10 oz Heinz sweet relish
2. New! 20 oz Heinz yellow mustard or 8 oz Heinz yellow mustard
3. New! 8 oz Baker’s imitation vanilla flavor
4. New! McCormick 1 oz banana extract
5. New! McCormick 30% less sodium mild chili seasoning mix
6. McCormick cocktail sauce for seafood
7. Western fat free dressing
8. Rumford baking powder
9. 12 oz Happy Belly pancake syrup
10. McCormick Sloppy Joes seasoning mix or McCormick mushroom gravy mix
11. Classico pizza sauce
12. Happy Belly ranch dressing
13. McCormick Grill Mates mesquite seasoning or McCormick sea salt grinder
14. Wish-Bone creamy Caesar dressing or ranch dressing or Wish-Bone chunky blue cheese dressing or red wine vinaigrette or light ranch dressing or Wish-Bone sweet & spicy honey mustard dressing or Wish-Bone balsamic vinaigrette or Wish-Bone Russian dressing or zesty Robusto Italian dressing
15. Kraft Tuscan House Italian dressing
16. Frank’s RedHot sauce 5 oz
17. Equal zero calorie 100 ct sweetener tablets

Personal care filler items

1. New! Dial liquid hand soap in coconut water & mango
2. Burt’s Bee’s for kids fluoride-free fruit fusion toothpaste
3. Reach waxed dental floss in mint
4. Speed Stick regular deodorant 3 oz
5. Aquafresh cavity protection paste or Aquafresh kids toothpaste in bubble mint
6. Blistex lip balm Medex or Blistex Five Star lip protection
7. Irish Spring 3 bar deodorant bar soap
8. Travel size Coppertone Sport sunscreen
9. 3 ct Colgate extra clean toothbrushes
10. .9 fl oz OPI Swiss Blue liquid hand soap
11. Summer’s Eve 16 ct sunset oasis cleansing cloth
12. Almay clear gel sensitive skin deodorant
13. 3 pack Dial antibacterial bar soap
14. Brush Buddies denture brush
15. 75 ct Plackers back teeth micro mint floss picks or 12 ct Plackers micro mint dental floss picks with travel case
16. Suave shower fresh deodorant
17. Listerine ultraclean 3.2 oz arctic mint mouthwash
18. Colgate baking soda & peroxide whitening paste

Cosmetics filler items

1. New! e.l.f. lip lacquer in wild rose
2. Revlon ColorStay gel envy nail polish in plum/berry
3. wet ‘n wild megalast liquid catsuit lipstick in flame of the game
4. wet ‘n wild megaliner metallic liquid eyeliner in cosmic black or in metallic brown
5. Three pack ChapStick classic cherry flavor or ChapStick 100% natural lip butter in green tea mint
6. Sally Hansen hard as nails color in cold as ice or Sally Hansen hard as nails color in heart of stone
7. wet ‘n wild color icon powder blush in pinch me pink
8. L.A. Colors chunky lip pencil in tierra cotta or chunky lip pencil in warm caramel or L.A. Colors chunky lip pencil in lilac
9. wet ‘n wild photo focus concealer in light honey
10. L.A. Colors two piece eyeliner/brow pencil with sharpener or eyeliner pencil in black
11. Lip Smackers lip balm in Dr Pepper
12. wet ‘n wild megaslicks lip gloss in red sensation
13. wet n’ wild mega last high shine lip color in peach please or wet ‘n wild megalast lip color in mauve outta here or wet ‘n wild megalast lip color in cherry bomb or wet ‘n wild megalast lip color in bare it all or in fire-fighting or wet ‘n wild megalast lip color in rose-bud
14. e.l.f. satin eyeliner pencil with built-in sharpener in black
15. silk finish lip stick in Just Garnet or wet n wild silk finish lip stick in blind date
16. wet n wild small concealer brush or wet n wild crease brush or wet ‘n wild large eyeshadow brush or small eyeshadow brush or wet ‘n wild angled liner brush

Other Beauty filler items

1. New! Caravan bugle bead barrette
2. New! One Direction our moment for women eau de parfum blotter cards
3. New! Blackhead remover 4 piece kit
4. Revlon nail clipper
5. Suave professionals shampoo shampoo, deep moisture or Suave Professionals sleek conditioner
6. Cutex nail polish remover
7. One Direction our moment for women eau de parfum spray vial
8. Clairol professional hair coloring developers for lightening
9. 15 ct Almay eye makeup remover pads
10. Revlon Issac Mizrahi nail shapers 2 pack
11. Diane wood applicator sticks
12. 7 ct Neutrogena makeup remover towelettes
13. Palmer’s olive oil formula deep conditioner packet or Palmer’s protein coconut oil pack
14. HELI’s GOLD restructure masque or HELI’s GOLD crystal cream serum
15. 2 ct TRIM salon boards
16. .25 oz L’ANZA healing colorcare clarifying shampoo

Health filler items

1. 10 ct travel size Advil
2. Ricola honey herb throat drops 24 ct
3. 10 ct Curad non-stick pads
4. Pac-Kit by First Aid Only 3″ gauze roll bandage
5. Luden’s 30 ct honey licorice cough drops or 25 ct Luden’s sugar free wild cherry cough drops
6. 10 ct travel size Aleve
7. Band-Aid Tru-Stay clear spots 50 ct
8. First Aid Only scissors & tweezers pack
9. Good Sense saline nasal spray
10. First Aid Only gauze compress
11. Fleet laxative saline enema 2 ct

Household filler items

1. New! Soft Scrub in-tank toilet cleaner duo-cubes
2. New! GE lighting specialty C7 incandescent light bulb in blue, 2 pack
3. New! 24 pc Dritz home antique brass decorative nails
4. Scotch-Brite stainless steel scrubbers 3 pack
5. Scotch-Brite non-scratch scour pads 3 pack
6. Scotch-Brite non-scratch plastic scrubbing pads 3 pack
7. Glade Plugins air freshener warmer
8. 40 ct Purex dryer sheets in mountain breeze
9. Radians indoor/outdoor safety glasses
10. White panel nails or Linoleum nails or 2 oz pack wire nails
11. Fels Naptha laundry bar & stain remover
12. Duracell 2016 3V lithium coin battery 1 ct

Pet filler items

1. New! Wardley goldfish pellet food
2. New! New! Fluker’s repta calcium
3. New! Aquaclear foam inserts
4. New! Fluval U1 underwater filter foam pad
5. New! MarineLand penguin rite-size cartridge
6. New! JW Playplace butterfly teether
7. New! Tetra weekend tropical slow release feeder
8. New! Vitakraft raviolos rabbit treats
9. New! C&C products Nyjer sack
10. New! .5 oz SmartyKat organic catnip
11. New! ExoTerra dual carbon pads
12. API stress coat water conditioner
13. Perky-Pet bird feed
14. Marina 3 inch blue fine nylon net
15. Ethical wide colorful springs cat toy
16. Fat Cat classic kitten little cat toy
17. ProSense itch solutions hydrocortisone spray for pets
18. Vitakraft Slims with alfalfa
19. Fluker’s gourmet style grasshoppers
20. Whisker Lickin’s tuna cat treats
21. BONIES natural calming small singles
22. Purebites Mixers pure wild tuna in water for cats
23. Petmate basic litter cat pan
24. Kaytee Yo Dips bird treats
25. SmartyKat catnip cat toys
26. Fluker’s tortoise diet large pellet food
27. Van Ness F6 Zeolite air filter
28. Tetra BettaMin floating mini pellets for bettas
29. Nylabone flavored DuraChew Power Chew dog toy or Nylabone durachew petit flavored dog toy or Nylabone puppy chew
30. Vitakraft sticks variety pack
31. Kaytee healthy treat toppings for small animals
32. nBone ferret chews in salmon flavor
33. eCOTRITION yogies for hamsters/gerbils/rats
34. Ware large rice pops small animal treats
35. Tetra Whisper bio-bag filter cartridges for aquariums 2 pack
36. Canine Carry Outs sausage links dog treats

Office and Art Supplies filler items

1. New! 3M general use masking tape
2. New! 3M blue prisma reflective tape roll
3. Avery Worksaver extra-wide insertable tab recycled dividers
4. Maddak hold-and-read
5. Avery write-on dividers for two-prong classification folders
6. Oxford 100 ct 3×5 index cards
7. Universal lightweight hand letter opener
8. Avery five tab binder dividers
9. Avery big tab dividers for 2 prong classification folders, set of 5
10. Avery triangle shaped sheet lifter for 3 ring binder
11. Avery extra-wide insertable tab recycled dividers
12. Avery WorkSaver tab inserts 100 ct

*** This list is updated each Thursday.

More Amazon deals?

If you just can’t get enough of that Amazon subscribe & save and other deals:

• Browse all Amazon subscribe & save items (and see current subscribe & save coupons!) here.
• Come join us in the Hot Deals Facebook group.

New to Amazon subscribe & save?

I’ve got your back! Here’s your step-by-step guide showing how to maximize your savings with Amazon subscribe & save.

---

Prices on Amazon often change quickly; price(s) current as of the time and date of this post. You can cancel subscribe & save or skip a shipment at any time. On MOST items, you get 5% off and free shipping with subscribe & save, or 15% off if you have five subscriptions on the same day/month. For more about coupons & subscribe & save, see the guide here.