Skip to Content

100+ cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save Items — Updated 1/20/22

Here are 100+ cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save items to help you get up to five subscriptions, for that magical 15% off most things in your subscribe & save order!

cheap amazon subscribe & save filler items

Last updated 1/20/22

  • As of the time & date of this post: Each Subscribe & Save filler item here is under $2.00 shipped on the 15% off (or five items) tier.
  • Add in one or two of these low cost fillers, & you’ll save more on your higher priced Subscribe & Save items.
  • Browse all Amazon Subscribe & Save items here.

As always, prices on Amazon can change at any time. Always check the current price before subscribing. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

100+ Cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save items under $2.00 each as of January 20, 2022

These Subscribe & Save filler items are under $2.00 each on the five items tier at the time of this post (since this is our goal!). Post is updated every Thursday.

*** Items marked New! are new to (or making a reappearance on) the list since last week.

Food & drink filler items

  1. New! Zatarain’s long grain & wild rice
  2. New! Green Giant cream style sweet corn
  3. New! Diamond of California 2.25 oz chopped walnuts
  4. New! Little Debbie 6 ct donut sticks
  5. 9 oz bag of Skittles
  6. David ranch jumbo sunflower seeds
  7. Del Monte:
    1. Del Monte canned French style green beans no salt added
    2. Del Monte Harvest Select crinkle cut pickled beets 16 oz
  8. Hamburger Helper:
    1. Hamburger Helper stroganoff twin pack
    2. Twin Pack Hamburger Helper beef pasta
  9. Nongshim Shin Ramyun package, spicy
  10. Happy Belly olives:
    1. Happy Belly large pitted black olives 6 oz
    2. Happy Belly sliced ripe olives 2.25 oz
  11. Chef Boyardee mac & cheese can
  12. 4 pack Snack Pack vanilla pudding cups
  13. Can of Ro-Tel
  14. Can of Manwich
  15. Happy Belly 10 pack lemonade drink mix singles
  16. 16 oz Happy Belly creamy peanut butter
  17. Zatarain’s rice:
    1. Zatarain’s red beans & rice
    2. Zatarain’s Spanish rice
  18. Swanson vegetable broth can
  19. True Lime limeade black cherry 10 ct

Condiments, baking items, & seasonings filler items

  1. New! Kraft dressing:
    1. Kraft Tuscan House Italian dressing 16 oz
    2. Kraft classic ranch fat free dressing 16 oz
  2. New! Simply Organic southwest taco seasoning mix
  3. New! Heinz Kansas City BBQ sauce
  4. New! Happy Belly extracts & food colorings:
    1. Happy Belly 1 fl oz green food coloring
    2. Happy Belly pure lemon extract 1 fl oz
  5. New! Edible by Design clear gel diamonds
  6. New! McCormick seasonings:
    1. McCormick gluten free chili seasoning
    2. McCormick Grill Mates tomato, garlic, & basil marinade mix
  7. New! Happy Belly Thousand Island dressing
  8. 10.2 oz Happy Belly powdered non-dairy French vanilla sugar free creamer
  9. 12 oz Clabber Girl baking soda
  10. 1 lb box Arm & Hammer baking soda
  11. Happy Belly 2 oz clear vanilla flavor extract
  12. 8 oz Iberia imitation vanilla extract
  13. Krusteaz honey cornbread & muffin mix
  14. Western sweet & smooth French fat free salad dressing
  15. Lawry’s marinades:
    1. Lawry’s teriyaki marinade
    2. Lawry’s steakhouse marinade
  16. Zatarain’s crawfish, shrimp, & crab boil
  17. It’s Delish spices:
    1. Garlic salt by It’s Delish
    2. It’s Delish bay leaves .65 oz
  18. Kraft salad dressing:
    1. Kraft classic Catalina salad dressing 16 oz
    2. Kraft classic Catalina salad dressing 8 oz
    3. Kraft chunky blue cheese dressing
    4. Kraft Parmesan pesto vinaigrette
    5. 8 oz Kraft Thousand Island dressing
  19. McCormick bac’n pieces imitation bacon bits
  20. McCormick seasonings and mixes:
    1. McCormick Grill Mates chipotle pepper marinade mix
    2. McCormick Grill Mates Baja citrus marinade mix
    3. McCormick Grill Mates garlic, herb, & wine marinade mix
    4. McCormick Grill Mates smokehouse maple seasoning
    5. McCormick Grill Mates mesquite seasoning
    6. McCormick 30% less sodium mild chili seasoning mix
    7. McCormick less sodium chili seasoning mix
    8. McCormick onion gravy mix
    9. McCormick turkey gravy mix
    10. McCormick brown gravy mix
    11. McCormick sea salt grinder
  21. 12 oz Rumford corn starch
  22. Jell-O:
    1. Jell-O chocolate pudding mix
    2. 6 oz Jell-O berry blue gelatin mix
  23. Happy Belly dressing:
    1. Happy Belly buttermilk ranch dressing
    2. Happy Belly traditional Italian dressing
    3. Happy Belly ranch dressing
    4. Happy Belly creamy Caesar dressing
  24. Kitchen Accomplice wicked tasty taco simmer sauce
  25. Wish-Bone salad dressing:
    1. Wish-Bone chunky blue cheese
    2. Wish-Bone red wine vinaigrette
    3. Wish-Bone fat free chunky blue cheese dressing
    4. Wish-Bone balsamic vinaigrette
    5. Wish-Bone zesty robusto Italian dressing 15 oz
    6. Wish-Bone light ranch dressing
    7. Wish-Bone light sweet & spicy French dressing
    8. Wish-Bone light creamy Caesar
    9. Wish-Bone chipotle ranch dressing
    10. Wish-Bone fat free ranch dressing
  26. Equal zero calorie sweetener tablets 100 ct

Personal care filler items

  1. 20 ct Carefree regular scented liners
  2. ChapStick total hydration lip balm in eucalyptus mint
  3. Almay clear gel sensitive skin deodorant
  4. 3.2 oz Listerine Ultraclean mouthwash (with $.26 coupon on the page)
  5. 3 oz Johnson’s baby oil
  6. Revlon compact mini nail clipper
  7. Travel size Edge men’s sensitive skin shave gel
  8. Softsoap liquid hand soap in aloe
  9. 12 ct Plackers micro mint dental floss picks with travel case
  10. Brush Buddies denture brush
  11. Arrid XX extra extra dry deodorant
  12. 3 oz Thayers alcohol-free witch hazel facial toner with aloe vera & cucumber
  13. Aquafresh cavity protection paste
  14. Colgate Kids cavity protection paste in bubble fruit
  15. 5 ct double edge safety razor blades by Kai
  16. Softsheen-Carson magic shaving powder with fragrance
  17. Himalaya purifying neem & turmeric cleansing bar
  18. .9 fl oz OPI Swiss Blue liquid hand soap

Cosmetics filler items

  1. New! e.l.f. ultra precise brow pencil in brunette
  2. New! Sally Hansen insta-dri nail polish in moonstone
  3. New! L.A. Colors Color Craze nail polish in circuits
  4. New! NYX:
    1. NYX lip primer, nude
    2. NYX tame & frame eyebrow pomade, blonde
    3. NYX eyebrow powder pencil, blonde
    4. NYX powder puff lippie lip cream in moody
  5. New! Black Radiance perfect tone lip color, boss brown
  6. Black Radiance concealer stick, dark
  7. NYX:
    1. NYX precision eyebrow pencil, espresso
    2. NYX HD studio photogenic concealer wand, nutmeg
  8. e.l.f. prime & stay finishing powder in sheer
  9. Sally Hansen nail:
    1. Sally Hansen ultimate shield base & top coat
    2. Sally Hansen hard as nails color in black heart
    3. Sally Hansen hard as nails, limestone
  10. L.A. Colors:
    1. L.A. Colors 2-piece eyeliner/brow pencil with sharpener, black
    2. L.A. Colors color craze nail polish in pink bubbles
    3. L.A. Colors day to night 12 color eyeshadow palette, dawn
  11. wet ‘n wild nail:
    1. wet ‘n wild shine nail color in kaleidoscope
    2. wet ‘n wild megalast nail color in haze of love
  12. wet ‘n wild eye:
    1. wet ‘n wild brow-sessive brow pencil in dark brown
    2. wet ‘n wild brow-sessive brow pencil in light brown/taupe
    3. wet ‘n wild mega last breakup-proof retractable eyeliner, black
  13. wet ‘n wild lip:
    1. wet ‘n wild mega last high shine lip color, fire-fighting
    2. wet ‘n wild mega last high shine lip color in pinky ring
    3. wet ‘n wild silk finish lipstick in black orchid
    4. wet ‘n wild silk finish lip stick in Just Garnet
    5. wet ‘n wild megaslicks lip gloss in rose gold

Other Beauty filler items

  1. New! Revlon Colorsilk:
    1. Revlon Colorsilk beautiful color in dark auburn
    2. Revlon Colorsilk beautiful color in light golden brown
  2. Yardley oatmeal & almond soap bar
  3. Pantene Pro-V intense rescue shots hair ampoule
  4. e.l.f. dual pencil sharpener
  5. wet ‘n wild dual pencil sharpener
  6. Cutex nail polish remover:
    1. Cutex ultra-powerful nail polish remover for gel, glitter, and dark colored paints
    2. Cutex strength shield nail polish remover
  7. 48 ct Goody slideproof women’s bobby pins in crimpled brown
  8. FILA fragrance:
    1. Eau de toilette for the active man, mini 1.5 ml
    2. Eau de toilette for the active woman, mini 1.5 ml
  9. 2 oz travel size NIVEA creme
  10. JOICO:
    1. JOICO ICE spiker colorz pink styling glue
    2. JOICO ICE spiker colorz blue styling glue
    3. JOICO spiker colorz, techno purple
  11. Neutrogena:
    1. Neutrogena original fragrance-free facial cleansing bar with glycerin
    2. 7 ct Neutrogena makeup remover cleansing towelettes
  12. Diane 3.5″ powder puff
  13. wet ‘n wild eyelash curler
  14. e.l.f. eyeshadow brush for precision application
  15. wet ‘n wild cosmetic brushes:
    1. wet n wild small concealer brush
    2. wet n wild crease brush
    3. wet ‘n wild large eyeshadow brush
    4. wet ‘n wild small eyeshadow brush
  16. HELI’s Gold voluminize shampoo
  17. L’ANZA:
    1. L’ANZA .25 oz color care trauma treatment shampoo
    2. .25 oz L’ANZA healing colorcare clarifying shampoo

Health filler items

  1. New! Six pack Radians foam earplugs
  2. New! Apex dayplanner
  3. 1 oz Gold Bond medicated talc-free body powder
  4. Band-Aid Tru-Stay clear spots bandages 50 ct
  5. GoodSense saline nasal spray
  6. Solimo isopropyl alcohol:
    1. 16 oz Solimo 50% isopropyl alcohol with wintergreen
    2. 16 oz Solimo 70% isopropyl alcohol with wintergreen
    3. Solimo 16 oz 50% isopropyl alcohol
  7. 10 ct travel pack Tylenol
  8. Amazon Basic Care aspirin 81 mg low dose 36 ct chewable orange tablets
  9. 10 ct morning pep prenatal vitamin tablets
  10. First Aid Only:
    1. First Aid Only hydrocortisone anti-itch cream 12 ct packets
    2. First Aid Only gauze compress
    3. First Aid Only antiseptic towelettes 10 ct
  11. Luden’s 30 ct honey licorice cough drops

Household filler items

  1. New! The Hillman Group upholstery tacks
  2. New! The Hillman Group upholstery nails
  3. New! VELCRO one-wrap bundling ties
  4. Scrubbing Bubbles toilet bowl cleaner
  5. Arm & Hammer fridge fresh refrigerator air filter
  6. Bondo tack cloth
  7. Duracell 2032 3V lithium coin battery
  8. Energizer 2016 3V lithium coin battery
  9. Electrical tape:
    1. Plymouth Revere general purpose electrical tape, yellow
    2. Plymouth Revere general purpose electrical tape, gray
    3. NSi WarriorWrap Select vinyl electrical tape, yellow
    4. NSi WarriorWrap Select vinyl electrical tape, green
    5. NSi WarriorWrap Select vinyl electrical tape, gray
    6. NSi WarriorWrap Select vinyl electrical tape, white
  10. 34 ct Bounce dryer sheets
  11. Westinghouse lighting 15W CST6 clear incandescent bulb w/ candelabra base
  12. FELS-NAPTHA laundry bar
  13. Sunlite 60CTC/32 incandescent 60 watt chandelier bulb
  14. Sprayaway 20 ct glass cleaner wipes
  15. Glade air:
    1. Glade clean linen solid air freshener
    2. Glade apple cinnamon room spray
    3. Glade room spray in cashmere woods
    4. Glade carpet & room refresher in Hawaiian Breeze
    5. Glade solid air freshener in lavender & peach blossom

Pet filler items

Dogs & cats

  1. New! SmartyKat organic catnip
  2. New! Pro Pac:
    1. Pro Pac bacon flavored jerky strips dog treats
    2. Pro Pac chick’n’meal sticks dog treats
    3. Pro Pac smoky sausage bites dog treats
    4. Pro Pac beef flavored woof ‘em down sticks
  3. New! JW Play Place butterfly dog teether
  4. New! EZ Dog fingerbrush dog toothbrush
  5. New! Wet Ones for pets wipes
  6. New! Whiskas Temptations hearty beef cat treats
  7. Temptations cat treats in creepy catnip
  8. Pioneer pet toy balls for cats 3 ct
  9. Pro Pac chick’n’meal chunx dog treats
  10. SmartyKat:
    1. SmartyKat skitter critters catnip mice
    2. SmartyKat catnip with silvervine
  11. Ethical toys:
    1. Ethical slotted balls cat toy 4 pack
    2. Ethical twin plush mice cat toy with rattle
  12. Yeowww catnip mini
  13. Hartz chew ‘n clean tuff bone dog chew toy
  14. Van Ness Zeolite air filter
  15. SmartyKat organic catnip
  16. Vet Worthy adhering wrap for dogs
  17. Nylabone Extreme Chew chicken flavored toy bone for petite X-small dogs
  18. Buddy Biscuits grain free cat treats
  19. Plato Thinkers treats:
    1. PLATO Thinkers singles salmon dog treat
    2. PLATO Thinkers lamb dog treat
    3. PLATO Thinkers duck dog treat
    4. Plato Thinkers dog treats chicken stick
  20. Mammoth flossy chews rope tug toy for dogs

Fish, amphibians, & reptiles

  1. New! Marina 2″ black coarse nylon net w/ 10″ handle
  2. New! Zoo Med box turtle food canned food
  3. New! Aqueon:
    1. Aqueon goldfish flakes
    2. Aqueon algae rounds
    3. Aqueon cichlid pellets
  4. Tetra:
    1. Tetra BettaMin small pellets
    2. Tetra weekend vacation tropical feeding block
  5. TetraFauna:
    1. TetraFauna Reptomin baby shrimp treat
    2. TetraFauna AquaSafe reptile & amphibian water conditioner
  6. Aqueon marine flakes
  7. Fluval:
    1. Fluval edge foam & biomax filter media renewal kit
    2. Fluval bug bites goldfish flakes
  8. Marina:
    1. Marina intake strainer sponge slim power filter
    2. Marina cool clam air stone, blue
    3. Marina Blue fine nylon net with handle XS 3″
  9. Penn-Plax:
    1. Penn-Plax QN2 quick net for fish 2″x1.75″
    2. Penn-Plax 8 ft standard airline tubing
    3. Penn-Plax cascade hang-on power filter replacement cartridges
    4. Penn-Plax aquarium fish net aqua green 4″
  10. Fluker’s reptile calcium supplement without vitamin D3
  11. Exo Terra adult aquatic turtle food

Birds & small animals

  1. New! Perky-Pet oriole instant nectar concentrate
  2. Peter’s Nature Treats apple slices
  3. Living World small animals mineral stone:
    1. Living World small animal minerals stone, corn
    2. Living World small animal minerals stone, carrot
  4. VitaKraft small animal & bird treats:
    1. Vitakraft sticks variety pack
    2. Vitakraft rabbit slims with carrot
  5. Kaytee small animal & bird treats:
    1. Kaytee food from the wild natural snack with pumpkin seed, rose petal, and carrot 2 oz
    2. Kaytee food from the wild natural snack with spinach and strawberries
    3. Kaytee Fiesta mango flavored YoDips bird treats

Office, School, and Art Supplies filler items

  1. New! Officemate pencil style moistener with wedge sponge
  2. New! Avery 315 ct multi-use round removable labels
  3. New! Cra-Z-Art 3 pack washable glue sticks
  4. New! Sharpie 2 ct fine point permanent markers
  5. New! Five Star fat lil’ pocket notebook
  6. New! Paper Mate:
    1. Paper Mate InkJoy 12 ct medium point ballpoint pens, black
    2. Paper Mate InkJoy gel pen medium point, black
  7. Prang chalk:
    1. Prang hygieia dustless chalk, assorted colors 12 ct
    2. Prang hygieia chalkboard chalk, yellow 12 ct
  8. Scotch glue stick
  9. Oxford heavyweight 100 ct 3×5 ruled index cards
  10. Cra-Z Art 8 ct washable watercolors
  11. Pilot Parallel Pen ink refills for calligraphy pens, blue black 6 ct
  12. Paper Mate:
    1. Paper Mate InkJoy 12 ct medium point ballpoint pens, blue
    2. Paper Mate InkJoy 12 ct medium ballpoint pens, red
  13. 2 ct Ticonderoga My First presharpened pencils
  14. Scotch glue stick
  15. Pentel:
    1. Pentel hi-polymer lead, .5 mm, HB 30 pack
    2. Pentel RSVP ballpoint pen, fine line, black ink, 2 pack
    3. Pentel hi-polymer lead .7 mm HB, tube of 30
    4. Pentel refill ink for BL57/BL77 EnerGel liquid gel pen .7 mm black ink
  16. The Hillman Group clear push pins 40 pack
  17. Prismacolor soft core colored pencil, warm grey
  18. ACCO binder clips:
    1. ACCO 12 ct small binder clips
    2. 12 ct ACCO large binder clips
  19. Apple Barrel acrylic paint 2 oz, key west
  20. Office Essentials plastic tab dividers, 8 clear tabs
  21. 10 ct Bic Xtra Life ballpoint pens, medium point blue
  22. Avery office supplies:
    1. Avery marks-a-lot large chisel tip permanent marker, black
    2. Avery deluxe clear front report cover with 3 double prong fasteners
    3. Avery glue stic two pack
    4. Avery jewelry tags pack of 100
    5. Avery translucent 2 pocket folder, blue
    6. Avery marks-a-lot permanent marker, desk-style size, chisel tip, black
  23. Avery labels:
    1. Avery fashion reinforcement labels 280 ct assorted metallic colors
    2. Avery round color coding labels 315 pack
    3. Avery 1×3 rectangular color coding labels 72 pack
    4. Avery removable labels, rectangular, white, 525 ct
    5. Avery removable multi-use labels, blue border, 10 pack
    6. Avery removable multi-use labels, blue border 15 pack
  24. Avery dividers:
    1. Avery 8-tab binder dividers, insertable multicolor big tabs
    2. Avery write & erase big tab paper dividers, 5-tab white
    3. Avery insertable dividers, buff paper 5 multicolor tabs
    4. Avery insertable tab index dividers 5 pack multicolor
    5. Avery 5 tab binder dividers, insertable clear big tabs 5 ct
  25. 12 pack Dixon #2 pencils
  26. Lion Design poly yellow envelope
  27. Sharpies:
    1. Sharpie twin tip fine & ultra fine permanent marker
    2. Two pack ultra fine point Sharpies
  28. Elmer’s washable gel school glue sticks 2 ct
  29. 3M 2090 .125″x60yd masking tape
  30. Delta Creative multi-surface paint 2 oz, shocking pink

*** This list is updated each Thursday.

New to Amazon Subscribe & Save?

I’ve got your back! Here’s your step-by-step guide showing how to maximize your savings with Amazon Subscribe & Save.

And, if you’re wondering how to cancel these subscriptions when they’re no longer needed: Here’s your step-to-step guide showing how to cancel Amazon Subscribe & Save.

Prices on Amazon often change quickly; price(s) current as of the time and date of this post. You can cancel subscribe & save or skip a shipment at any time. On many items, you get 5% off and free shipping with Subscribe & Save, or 15% off if you have five subscriptions arriving at the same time.

Simple Share Buttons