100+ cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save Items — Updated 9/16/21

Last updated 9/16/21

Here are 100+ cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save items to help you get up to five subscriptions, for that magical 15% off most things in your subscribe & save order!

• As of the time & date of this post: Each Subscribe & Save filler item here is under $2.00 shipped on the 15% off (or five items) tier.
• Add in one or two of these low cost fillers, & you’ll save more on your higher priced Subscribe & Save items.

As always, prices on Amazon can change at any time. Always check the current price before subscribing. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

100+ Cheap Amazon Subscribe & Save items under $2.00 each as of Sept. 16, 2021

These Subscribe & Save filler items are under $2.00 each on the five items tier at the time of this post (since this is our goal!). Post is updated every Thursday.

Items marked New! are new to (or making a reappearance on) the list since last week.

Food & drink filler items

1. New! Chef Boyardee mac & cheese can
2. New! GM cereal:
   1. Lucky Charms cereal
   2. Honey Nut Cheerios cereal
3. New! 4 pack apple cinnamon GoGo squeeZ
4. New! 10 pack Capri Sun Pacific Cooler
5. Can of Manwich
6. Hunt’s 4 cheese spaghetti sauce can
7. GoGo squeeZ apple strawberry 4 pack
8. 9 oz original Skittles
9. 5.25 oz David jumbo ranch sunflower seeds
10. Excelsior water crackers, 11.85 oz
11. Happy Belly 10 pack lemonade drink mix singles
12. 8.25 oz Kitchen Basics original chicken stock
13. 16 oz Happy Belly creamy peanut butter
14. Happy Belly crackers:
    1. Happy Belly original snack crackers 13.7 oz
    2. Happy Belly original saltine crackers
15. Zatarain’s rice:
    1. Zatarain’s red beans & rice
    2. Zatarain’s Spanish rice
16. Swanson vegetable broth can
17. True Lime limeade black cherry 10 ct

Condiments, baking items, & seasonings filler items

1. New! McCormick less sodium chili seasoning mix
2. New! Rumford corn starch
3. New! Kraft classic ranch fat free dressing
4. Iberia Mojo Criollo marinating sauce
5. 4 oz corn starch
6. It’s Delish bay leaves .65 oz
7. 8 oz Lawry’s seasoned salt
8. Kraft dressing:
   1. Kraft Tuscan House Italian dressing
   2. Kraft classic Catalina salad dressing (8 oz)
9. Duncan Hines caramel brownie mug cakes mix (clip 20% off coupon)
10. Happy Belly creamer:
    1. Happy Belly non-dairy sugar free French vanilla creamer
    2. Happy Belly original non-dairy coffee creamer
    3. Happy Belly powdered non-dairy original coffee creamer, fat free 16 oz
11. McCormick bac’n pieces imitation bacon bits
12. McCormick seasonings and mixes:
    1. McCormick onion gravy mix
    2. McCormick Grill Mates Baja citrus marinade mix
    3. McCormick sea salt grinder
    4. McCormick Grill Mates smokehouse maple seasoning
    5. McCormick Grill Mates chipotle pepper marinade mix
    6. McCormick Grill Mates mesquite seasoning
13. Clabber Girl baking:
    1. Clabber Girl 12 oz baking soda
    2. Clabber Girl 6.5 oz corn starch
14. Lawry’s signature steakhouse marinade 12 oz
15. 6 oz Jell-O berry blue gelatin mix
16. Spicely organic cardamom pods .2 oz
17. Happy Belly chili powder
18. Happy Belly dressing:
    1. Happy Belly ranch dressing
    2. Happy Belly traditional Italian dressing
    3. Happy Belly creamy Caesar dressing
    4. Happy Belly buttermilk ranch dressing
    5. Happy Belly Thousand Island dressing
19. Kitchen Accomplice wicked tasty taco simmer sauce
20. Zatarain’s crawfish, shrimp, & crab boil
21. Wish-Bone salad dressing:
    1. Wish-Bone chunky blue cheese
    2. Wish-Bone red wine vinaigrette
    3. Wish-Bone fat free chunky blue cheese dressing
    4. Wish-Bone balsamic vinaigrette
    5. Wish-Bone ranch dressing 15 oz
    6. Wish-Bone zesty robusto Italian dressing 15 oz
    7. Wish-Bone light ranch dressing
    8. Wish-Bone light sweet & spicy French dressing
    9. Wish-Bone sweet & spicy honey mustard dressing
    10. Wish-Bone sweet & spicy French dressing
22. Equal zero calorie sweetener tablets 100 ct

Personal care filler items

1. New! Edge 2.75 oz sensitive skin shave gel
2. New! ChapStick:
   1. ChapStick natural lip butter in green tea mint
   2. 3 pack ChapStick S’mores collection lip balm
3. New! SoftSheen-Carson magic shaving powder, regular strength
4. New! SoftSheen-Carson dark & lovely fade resist hair color in vivacious red
5. Suave men’s Sport body wash
6. Softsheen-Carson magic shaving powder regular strength
7. Kids Crest cavity protection bubble gum toothpaste
8. Revlon nail clipper
9. Dial antibacterial liquid hand soap in spring water
10. Brush Buddies denture brush
11. Reach waxed dental floss in mint
12. Colgate Kids cavity protection paste in bubble flavor
13. Plackers back teeth micro mint dental floss picks 75 ct
14. Suave powder roll-on deodorant
15. Dial antibacterial bar soap 3 pack gold bars
16. Arrid XX extra extra dry deodorant
17. 16 ct Summer’s Eve fragrance free cleansing cloths
18. Himalaya purifying neem & turmeric cleansing bar
19. 3.2 oz Listerine ultraclean
20. .9 fl oz OPI Swiss Blue liquid hand soap

Cosmetics filler items

1. New! L.A. Colors day to night eyeshadow palette in sundown
2. New! wet ‘n wild megalast nail color in haze of love
3. New! Revlon ColorStay lip liner in plum
4. New! Cover Girl exhibitionist lipstick in bestie boo
5. New! Maybelline baby lips moisturizing lip balm in cherry me
6. New! Sally Hansen ultimate shield base & top coat
7. New! NYX tame & frame eyebrow pomade in blonde
8. New! NYX liquid suede cream lipstick in oh put it on (deep dark purple)
9. New! wet ‘n wild silk finish lipstick in pink ice
10. New! Revlon nail enamel in totally toffee (nude/brown)
11. New! Black Radiance perfect tone lip color in sundrenched bronze
12. NYX powder puff lippie lip cream in pop quiz (berry)
13. Revlon super lustrous lipstick in gold goddess
14. Sally Hansen nail polish:
    1. Sally Hansen Hard as Nails color in cold as ice
    2. Sally Hansen hard as nails in black heart
15. Black Radiance concealer stick, light
16. Black Radiance lash lengthening mascara in black
17. e.l.f. prime & stay finishing powder in light/medium
18. e.l.f. satin eyeliner pencil with built in sharpener
19. L.A. Colors:
    1. L.A. Colors brow pencil with spool
    2. L.A. Colors 2-piece eyeliner/brow pencil with sharpener
20. wet ‘n wild liner:
    1. wet ‘n wild megalast breakup-proof retractable eyeliner, black
    2. wet ‘n wild kohl liner pencil in baby’s got black
21. wet ‘n wild browsessive brow pencil in dark brown
22. wet ‘n wild mega last lip color:
    1. wet ‘n wild mega last high shine lip color in fire-fighting
    2. wet ‘n wild mega last high shine lip color in pinky ring
23. wet ‘n wild silk finish lipstick:
    1. wet ‘n wild silk finish lipstick in black orchid
    2. wet ‘n wild silk finish lip stick in Just Garnet
    3. wet ‘n wild silk finish lipstick in light berry frost
24. wet ‘n wild megaslicks lip gloss
    1. wet ‘n wild megaslicks lip gloss in strawberry ice
    2. wet ‘n wild megaslicks lip gloss in rose gold

Other Beauty filler items

1. New! Yardley cocoa butter & vitamin E bar soap
2. Pantene intense rescue shots hair ampoule
3. Yardley shea buttermilk bar soap
4. Suave Professionals shampoo + conditioner 12.6 oz
5. Cutex nail polish remover:
   1. Cutex strength shield nail polish remover
   2. Cutex ultra-powerful nail polish remover for gel, glitter, and dark colored paints
6. Jergens original scent 3 oz cherry almond moisturizer
7. Neutrogena original fragrance-free facial cleansing bar with glycerin
8. Queen Helene cocoa butter face & body creme
9. butter LONDON banana nail file
10. 2 oz NIVEA creme
11. Diane 3.5″ powder puff
12. 7 ct Neutrogena makeup remover cleansing towelettes
13. wet ‘n wild eyelash curler
14. Revlon & Barbie nail shaper
15. e.l.f. products:
    1. e.l.f. brightening lemon-infused mask
    2. e.l.f. eyeshadow brush for precision application
    3. e.l.f. dual pencil sharpener
16. Yardley oatmeal & almond bar soap
17. WELLA color tango developer
18. wet ‘n wild cosmetic brushes:
    1. wet n wild small concealer brush
    2. wet n wild crease brush
    3. wet ‘n wild large eyeshadow brush
    4. wet ‘n wild small eyeshadow brush
    5. wet ‘n wild angled liner brush
19. Aussie 3 minute miracle moist deep conditioning treatment
20. The Face Shop real nature mask sheet in olive
21. Clairol hair developers:
    1. Clairol professional pure white hair developers for lightening
    2. Clairol professional developers for lightening
    3. Clairol professional true color hair creme developers
22. HELI’s Gold:
    1. HELI’s Gold voluminize shampoo
    2. HELI’s GOLD restructure masque
23. L’ANZA:
    1. L’ANZA .3 oz glossifying shampoo
    2. .25 oz L’ANZA healing colorcare clarifying shampoo
    3. L’ANZA healing ColorCare trauma treatment

Health filler items

1. 10 ct travel pack Tylenol
2. Ricola natural honey herb drops 24 ct
3. Amazon Basic Care aspirin 81 mg low dose 36 ct chewable orange tablets
4. GoodSense saline nasal spray
5. 10 ct morning pep prenatal vitamin tablets
6. First Aid Only:
   1. First Aid Only hydrocortisone anti-itch cream 12 ct packets
   2. First Aid Only gauze compress
7. Luden’s cough drops:
   1. Luden’s 30 ct honey licorice cough drops
   2. 25 ct Luden’s sugar free wild cherry cough drops
   3. Luden’s 30 ct wild cherry throat drops

Household filler items

1. New! Sprayaway 20 ct glass cleaner wipes
2. New! Satco S3786 120 volt candelabra base frost bulb
3. New! Rubbermaid commercial large disposable mop
4. New! Bulbrite KR15CFC/25 15W chandelier bulb (CA8)
5. New! Scrubbing Bubbles toilet bowl cleaner
6. Creative Converting no. 8 birthday numeral candle
7. Frost King vinyl foam tape
8. GAM wall scraper
9. Satco bulbs:
   1. Satco A3640 130V medium base 25 watt G25 bulb
   2. Satco S3171 10 watt T3 halogen dimmable bulb
   3. Satco S3248 bayonet base 25 watt T6.5 bulb
   4. Satco S6050 25 watt A19 soft white frosted bulb 2 pack
10. Sunlite 60 watt chandelier bulb
11. Sprayaway glass cleaner aerosol spray 19 oz
12. Glade air:
    1. Glade room spray in crisp waters
    2. Glade clean linen solid air freshener
13. Renuzit gel air freshener in pure breeze
14. Soft Scrub 4-in-1 toilet care in sapphire waters
15. 3M .25″x60yd general use masking tape
16. Bulbrite KR25CFC/32 25w chandelier bulb (CA10)
17. FELS-NAPTHA laundry bar & stain remover
18. Duracell coin batteries:
    1. Duracell 2032 3V lithium coin battery
    2. Duracell 2016 3V lithium coin battery
19. Magid gemstone diamond protective visitor glasses
20. 40 ct Purex dryer sheets in mountain breeze
21. 34 ct Bounce dryer sheets in outdoor fresh

Pet filler items

Dogs & cats

1. New! Hartz Just for Cats 100% pure catnip 1 oz
2. New! Dingo tartar and breath dental sticks for dogs
3. Glad for Pets dog waste bags + dispenser
4. Van Ness Zeolite air filter
5. Mammoth flossy chews twister toy with tennis balls
6. SmartyKat skitter critters catnip mice
7. BONIES natural dental minis 2 bone pack
8. Vitakraft meaty morsels mini treats for dogs, chicken
9. Fresh Step drawstring cat litter box liners 7 ct
10. Ethical Pet:
    1. Ethical Pet SPOT fleece dog bone toy
    2. Ethical Pet bambone plus bamboo stick dog chew toy
11. Vet Worthy:
    1. Vet Worthy pill gun for dogs
    2. Vet Worthy soft fingerbrushes for dogs
12. Nylabone:
    1. Nylabone Extreme Chew chicken flavored toy bone for petite X-small dogs
    2. Nylabone Dura Chew bacon flavored bone dog chew toy, X-small
13. HDP Spot mylar balls cat toys
14. Buddy Biscuits grain free cat treats
15. Plato Thinkers treats:
    1. PLATO Thinkers singles salmon dog treat
    2. PLATO Thinkers real meat sticks
    3. PLATO Thinkers lamb dog treat
    4. PLATO Thinkers duck dog treat
    5. PLATO Thinkers chicken sticks
16. Pro-Pac treats:
    1. Pro Pac Chick’n’meal sticks treats
    2. Pro Pac smoky sausage bites dog treats
    3. Pro Pac beef flavored woof ’em down sticks dog treats
    4. Pro Pac bacon flavored jerky strips dog treats
17. JW Playplace butterfly teether
18. Mammoth flossy chews rope tug toy for dogs
19. Whisker Lickin’s tuna cat treats

Fish, amphibians, & reptiles

1. New! AquaClear 30 activated carbon insert A602
2. Fluval Clearmax 2-pack bio-foam cartridges for Fluval U3 aquarium filter
3. TetraFauna conditioner:
   1. TetraFauna ReptoGuard turtle health conditioner 3 ct
   2. TetraFauna AquaSafe water conditioner for reptiles & amphibians
4. Marina Blue fine nylon net with handle x-small 3″
5. Fluker’s:
   1. Fluker’s gourmet style river shrimp
   2. Fluker’s reptile calcium supplement without vitamin D3
6. Exo Terra adult aquatic turtle food
7. API stress coat water conditioner
8. Wardley betta food
9. Tetra BettaMin small pellets

Birds & small animals

1. New! Perky-Pet oriole nectar concentrate
2. New! Wild Harvest natural treat mix
3. Living World small animals mineral stone:
   1. Living World small animal minerals stone, corn
   2. Living World small animal minerals stone, carrot
4. Kaytee bird treats:
   1. Kaytee Fiesta mango flavored YoDips bird treats
   2. Kaytee blueberry flavored yogurt dipped sunflower seeds for birds
5. VitaKraft small animal & bird treats:
   1. VitaKraft nibble rings
   2. VitaKraft raviolos rabbit & guinea pig treats
   3. Vitakraft sticks variety pack
   4. Vitakraft Slims with alfalfa
   5. Vitakraft rabbit slims with carrot
6. Kaytee small animal treats:
   1. Kaytee Timothy biscuits baked carrot treat
   2. Kaytee food from the wild natural snack with spinach & strawberries
7. nBone ferret treats:
   1. nBone ferret chews in bacon flavor
   2. nBone ferret chews in salmon flavor

Office and Art Supplies filler items

1. New! 12 ct Paper Mate Write Bros. medium black ballpoint pens
2. New! 12 ct Bic Xtra comfort blue medium ballpoint pens
3. New! Sharpies:
   1. Sharpie twin tip fine and ultra fine permanent marker
   2. 2 pack Sharpie fine point permanent markers
   3. 2 pack Sharpie ultra fine point permanent markers
   4. A single magenta Sharpie
4. New! 12 ct ACCO small binder clips
5. Business Source ring binder accessories 8 tab 1/2″ index dividers
6. Prismacolor Premier soft core colored pencil, powder blue
7. 3 oz Elmer’s liquid disappearing purple school glue
8. 3M 2090 .125″x60yd masking tape
9. Pentel ink:
   1. Pentel refill ink for EnerGel liquid gel pen, blue
   2. Pentel refill ink for Pentel RSVP ballpoint pen, fine line, blue ink
10. Aleene’s original tacky glue 2 oz
11. FolkArt paint:
    1. FolkArt extreme glitter acrylic paint 2 oz, turquoise
    2. FolkArt metallic acrylic paint 2 oz, silver sterling
12. Delta Creative multi-surface paint 2 oz, shocking pink

*** This list is updated each Thursday.

More Amazon deals?

If you just can’t get enough of that Amazon Subscribe & Save and other deals:

• Browse all Amazon Subscribe & Save items here.
• Come join us in the Hot Deals Facebook group.

New to Amazon Subscribe & Save?

I’ve got your back! Here’s your step-by-step guide showing how to maximize your savings with Amazon Subscribe & Save.

---

Prices on Amazon often change quickly; price(s) current as of the time and date of this post. You can cancel subscribe & save or skip a shipment at any time. On many items, you get 5% off and free shipping with Subscribe & Save, or 15% off if you have five subscriptions arriving at the same time. For more about coupons & subscribe & save, see the guide here.